Which is Better – Aluminum or Vinyl Fencing?

Which is Better – Aluminum or Vinyl Fencing?

Making The Choice Between Aluminum & Vinyl Fencing.

Vinyl fencing and aluminum fencing each have their strengths and weaknesses. Although either option is a solid choice, the best fence ultimately comes down to personal needs and preferences. Consider why you want a fence in the first place. Are you looking to add privacy? Do you want to boost the curb appeal of your Winchester home? Perhaps you need to mark your property lines. The reason for your fence will help guide you in the right direction. 

vinyl fencing
aluminum fencing

Key Comparison Points For Your Winchester Fencing Seach.

The best way to choose between aluminum and vinyl fencing is to break down key comparison points so you can make your selection based on characteristics that are important to you. 

Style

The look of vinyl fencing was inspired by traditional wood fencing. In fact, many vinyl styles are designed with faux wood grain. Much like wooden fences, vinyl fencing has wide pickets and usually makes a bold statement in any environment. Aluminum fencing is much daintier in comparison, inspired by ornamental wrought iron. It tends to blend in with its surroundings because the pickets are narrow and usually spaced far enough apart to easily see through them. 

Security

Although aluminum is lightweight, it’s undoubtedly strong—even more so than vinyl. Aluminum fencing is available with spear-shaped picket-tops to stop intruders and can even be made from commercial-grade aluminum alloy for higher security applications. Vinyl fencing is a great deterrent but doesn’t offer the same strength and durability as aluminum.

Privacy

If you want more privacy, vinyl is the clear choice. With interlocking privacy panels, various heights, and top rail accents, you can customize a vinyl privacy fence that will look great for decades. Although there are high-end, flat-paneled aluminum fences available on the market, they are less common and come at a higher price point.

Maintenance

Both vinyl and aluminum are maintenance-free. You should never have to do more than the occasional wash with soap and water to keep them looking brand new for years. Through Dutch Way, both options are backed with industry-leading manufacturer warranties, so you can rest assured your fence will last.

Cost

Aluminum and vinyl fencing are very comparably priced. Each product has endless style, color and finishing options that can be customized to suit your budget. The best place to start? A free estimate from Dutch Way!

Your Winchester Vinyl Fencing Supplier.

Whether you choose aluminum or vinyl fencing, it’s wise to consult with the experts. Not all fencing products are created equal, so you want to be sure you’re investing in a fence that is made to last and is backed by a great warranty. Unsure where to start with your Winchester fencing project? Give Dutch Way a call! Our pros will offer an on-site visit to help guide you through the process of selecting the perfect vinyl fencing or aluminum fencing product that will exceed your expectations! 

Let’s get your fencing project started!

Customer Reviews

Our customers love
our work. Here’s why.

star iconstar iconstar iconstar iconstar icon

Bridget Smith

Dutch Way came this morning to begin the process of our vinyl fence. They have been extremely polite and easy to work with, knowledgable, patient and professional as we changed our minds a few times about what we wanted. Our fence posts are just starting to be put in, but I would already highly recommend them! Can’t wait to see the finished product.

star iconstar iconstar iconstar iconstar icon

Ryan Kline

Only place to go if you are looking for a quality fence at a reasonable price. The staff are professional and care about doing a quality job and making the customer happy. Thanks for everything Dutch Way! I wouldn’t use anyone else!

star iconstar iconstar iconstar iconstar icon

Sarah & Tom Ferguson

We are very pleased with the beautiful decking, railing, and lattice recently installed at our home. Visitors have commented on how great it looks. Claude and Justin are very skilled, talented, patient, and steadfast. You have two very valuable employees who handle working under less-than-pleasant conditions and nasty weather with professionalism and grace. Most happy to give Dutch Way company and their employees a great review!

News

Get the inside scoop about the newest trends, products and techniques in the fencing, railing and decking world.

Vinyl fence cleaning

Fence Cleaning Made Simple: What Every Homeowner Should Know

Cleaning your fence doesn’t have to be complicated, but the right approach depends on the material. Learn how to care for wood, vinyl and aluminum fencing while keeping maintenance to a minimum.
Vinyl Fencing

Is a Fence Required for an Above-Ground Pool?

Albemarle County homeowners: find out if pool fencing is required for your above-ground or in-ground pool. Learn about state regulations, safety tips, quality materials and professional installation.